thegooddoctor
9/25/2016
When I read this novel, I rated it C, which I consider to be 1 1/2 stars. This would be pretty low for a novel that won a Nebula (and was nominated for a Hugo). But - all Nebulas (and Hugos) are NOT created equal!
In my rating system, a C - gets one star, and I increase by a half-star with each step up to an A+, which gets 5 stars. One half star is reserved for BOMB... D+ and lower.