thegooddoctor
2/17/2021
My rating is very low, because Frank Herbert, despite being an amazing SF author, is no better at posthumous collaborations than other mortals. For those of us die-hard fans of Dune, we have to remember that Herbert senior only wrote 6 dune novels, and we are deluding ourselves to think we can magically discover more.
My ratings system: I start with one star being equivalent to a rating of C -. I then go up one step at a time, to 5 stars being equivalent to a rating of A+. I have set aside one half star for BOMBS - books with a rating of D, E, F.