| 
 | ||
| Random quote:  "The way I see it, being dead is not terribly far off from being on a cruise ship. Most of your time is spent lying on your back. The brain has shut down. The flesh begins to soften. Nothing much new happens, and nothing is expected of you." ― Mary Roach, Stiff: The Curious Lives of Human Cadavers - (Added by: Acknud) | 
|  2015 Hugo Awards Discussion Moderators: Admin Jump to page : 1 2 3 4 5 Now viewing page 5 [25 messages per page] | View previous thread :: View next thread | 
| General Discussion -> Books, Awards & Lists | Message format | 
| Administrator  | 
 | ||
|  Admin Posts: 4101  Location: Dallas, Texas | Scott Laz - 2015-04-27  3:45 PM     Just catching up on the forums after being buried in work for the last few months. I’m very glad to see that this debacle has increased awareness of how the Hugo works and the importance of the nominating process. The hope is that more people will get involved, so that such tactics become less likely to succeed in the future. I’ll be voting “no award” in some categories, but there are three novels on the ballot that IMO could be worthy winners (which is actually not unusually low, based on past shortlists), so they’ll move up the reading list. For a good discussion/review of the novel nominees, see this week’s Coode Street podcast! 
 That's a good episode! I love that they completely bypassed the controversy and just talked about the books. Coode Street should be a staple for anyone interested in genre fiction. | ||
| 
 | |||
| illegible_scribble  | 
 | ||
|  Uber User Posts: 1057  | Scott Laz - 2015-04-28  8:45 AM For a good discussion/review of the novel nominees, see this week’s Coode Street podcast! Thanks for that; I'm on the third novel right now, so I'm going to bookmark it until after I've read the books. | ||
| 
 | |||
| illegible_scribble  | 
 | ||
|  Uber User Posts: 1057  | 
 “I can’t in good conscience complain about the deck being stacked against me, and then feel good about being nominated for an award when the deck gets stacked in my favor. That would make me a hypocrite. I can’t be part of that and still maintain my integrity.” “While I firmly believe that free speech is only truly free if everyone is allowed to speak their mind, I believe equally strongly that defending people’s right to free speech comes with responsibilities: in this case, the responsibility to call out unproductive, mean-spirited, inflammatory, and downright hateful speech. I believe that far too many of Vox’s words fall into those categories — and a stand has to be made against it.” And he's offering a very nice, curated sample packet from the Intergalactic Medicine Show's archives. "Of course, I always think more reading is a good thing. Reading is awesome. Reading — fiction, specifically — has been proven to make people more empathetic, and God knows we need as much empathy as we can possibly get these days. I also believe that when readers give new works by new authors an honest chance, they’ll find things they appreciate and enjoy." "In that spirit, I am taking the material that would have comprised my part of the Hugo Voters Packet and making it available to everyone, everywhere, for free, whether they have a WorldCon membership or not. Take it. Read it. Share it. It’s yours to do with as you will." | ||
| 
 | |||
| Engelbrecht  | 
 | ||
|  Uber User Posts: 462  | So who else is waiting with bated breath for the Hugo announcements this evening?   | ||
| 
 | |||
| valashain  | 
 | ||
|  Uber User Posts: 1465  Location: The Netherlands | Ceremony starts at 5am for me so I think I'll just read the results tomorrow :P | ||
| 
 | |||
| Administrator  | 
 | ||
|  Admin Posts: 4101  Location: Dallas, Texas | Engelbrecht - 2015-08-22  3:12 PM  So who else is waiting with bated breath for the Hugo announcements this evening?      There's a live simulcast for the ceremony. I'll probably watch it so I can get the site updated right away. http://www.ustream.tv/hugo-awards  | ||
| 
 | |||
| valashain  | 
 | ||
|  Uber User Posts: 1465  Location: The Netherlands | Well now, that was quite a beating for the puppies. No doubt they'll claim victory but I guess this proves that states won't win you an actual award. | ||
| 
 | |||
| valashain  | 
 | ||
|  Uber User Posts: 1465  Location: The Netherlands | Reading up on some of the fallout from the ceremony. So much bitterness. I have a feeling next year is going to be rocky for the Hugos as well. | ||
| 
 | |||
| Badseedgirl  | 
 | ||
|  Uber User Posts: 369  Location: Middle TN, USA | I watched it on ustream last night and when it became obvious how the votes were going, I started to see some sour grapes in the comment section. But it was a non-puppy sweep and I also had a very bad feeling about next years awards. Regardless of what GRM said in the preshow, I'm afraid a rule change may be in line. | ||
| 
 | |||
| Administrator  | 
 | ||
|  Admin Posts: 4101  Location: Dallas, Texas | Badseedgirl - 2015-08-23  7:52 AM  I watched it on ustream last night and when it became obvious how the votes were going, I started to see some sour grapes in the comment section.  But it was a non-puppy sweep and I also had a very bad feeling about next years awards.  Regardless of what GRM said in the preshow, I'm afraid a rule change may be in line. At least next year everyone will be on guard from the get go. There will be a counter campaign ready to go if needed. I'm afraid the Hugo has become a battleground rather than a celebration for genre fiction. 
 | ||
| 
 | |||
| Administrator  | 
 | ||
|  Admin Posts: 4101  Location: Dallas, Texas | Here's the link to the full Hugo voting results: http://sasquan.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/2015_Hugo_Final_Report.pdf | ||
| 
 | |||
| valashain  | 
 | ||
|  Uber User Posts: 1465  Location: The Netherlands | Hmm, Vox Day may give it another go but I do hope the sad puppies will see which way the wind is blowing. | ||
| 
 | |||
| Bormgans  | 
 | ||
|  Regular Posts: 99  Location: Belgium | excellent, well-researched piece on the controversy: http://www.wired.com/2015/08/won-science-fictions-hugo-awards-matte... | ||
| 
 | |||
| Jump to page : 1 2 3 4 5 Now viewing page 5 [25 messages per page] | 
| Search this forum Printer friendly version E-mail a link to this thread | 
Books
				BOOK AWARDS
				Hugo Award
				Nebula Award
				BSFA Award
				Mythopoeic Award
				Locus SF Award
				Locus Fantasy Award
				Locus FN Award
				Locus YA Award
				Locus Horror Award
				August Derleth Award
				Robert Holdstock Award
				Campbell Award
				World Fantasy Award
				Prometheus Award
				Aurora Award
				PKD Award
				Clarke Award
				Stoker Award
				Otherwise Award
				Aurealis SF Award
				Aurealis Fantasy Award
				Aurealis Horror Award
				Andre Norton Award
				Shirley Jackson Award
				Red Tentacle Award
				Golden Tentacle Award
				Legend Award
				Morningstar Award
				Nommo Award
			
				BOOK LISTS
				Classics of SF
				SF Mistressworks
				Guardian: The Best SF/F
				NPR: Top 100 SF/F
				Pringle Best 100 SF
				Pringle Modern Fantasy
				SF: 101 Best 1985-2010
				Fantasy 100
				ISFDB Top 100
				Horror 100
				Nightmare Magazine 100
				HWA Reading List
				Locus Best SF
				200 Significant SF Books by Women
				David Brin's YA List
				Baen Military SF List
				Defining SF Books:
				50s | 60s | 70s | 80s | 90s
				SF by Women Writers
				A Crash Course in the History of Black Science Fiction
			
Authors
			Top Authors
			All Authors
			All Women Authors
			AUTHOR AWARDS
			Damon Knight Memorial
			World Horror Convention
			WFA Life Achievement
			
			Cordwainer Smith Rediscovery
			AUTHOR LISTS
			Starmont Reader's Guide
			
		
Publishers
			Top Publishers
			All Publishers
			PUBLISHER LISTS
			Ace Doubles Series:
			D | F | G | H | M | #
			Conversation Pieces
			Classic Library of SF
			Critical Explorations in SF&F
									
			EP Masterpieces of SF
			Fantasy Masterworks
			SF Masterworks
			Laser Books
			Liverpool SF Texts and Studies
			Author's Choice Monthly
			Pulphouse Short Stories
			Winston SF
		
Resources
			Podcasts
			BookTubers
			Magazines
			Conventions
			eBooks
			Bookstores
			SF/F/H Sub-Genres
			Websites
			Clubs & Groups
		
WWEnd
			BookTrackr™
			
			The Responsible Parties
			WWEnd Patrons
			Support WWEnd
			Advertise on WWEnd
			FAQ
			Contact Us
		
My World
Sign Up now and enjoy the enhanced features only available to members.
Blog
			
			ASMR: Sauron’s Helmet from The Lord of the Rings, Sculpted in Wood
In Time for Banned Books Week: A Massive Update to Our List
2025 Nommo Awards Shortlist
2025 Hugo Award Winner
2025 Aurora Award Winner
			
		
Forums
Home | © 2025 Tres Barbas, LLC. All rights reserved.
| (Delete all cookies set by this site) | |















 
							
 
									 
									
 Full Details
 Full Details Forgot your Password?
 Forgot your Password?
 
			 
  


