open

Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Forums

You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Random quote: "Seeing, contrary to popular wisdom, isn't believing. It's where belief stops, because it isn't needed any more." - Terry Pratchett
- (Added by: Administrator)


Magical Realism
Moderators: Admin

Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [25 messages per page]		View previous thread :: View next thread
   General Discussion -> SF/F/H ChatMessage format
 
minervasowl
Posted 2013-05-29 9:44 AM (#5140)
Subject: Magical Realism



Member

Posts: 24
0
Location: New Hampshire

The tweet about Salman Rushdie being a fantasy author has inspired me to start a conversation about magical realism because his writing falls into that category as well (or one might argue that it's the same category). Gabriel Garcia Marquez and Isabel Allende are two of my favorite authors. They get shelved in literature/fiction sections in bookstores, but their writing has distinct fantastical aspects. Toni Morrison, too. I have even seen Angela Carter included in magical realism discussions. Someone once told me that quintessential speculative/sf/f/h fiction is a story in which one fantastic element is incorporated into an otherwise realistic setting. Is magical realism just another way to say urban fantasy? Or speculative fiction? Do we stop worrying about specific definitions and just read good books with stories that take one or more steps away from "the real world"?Thoughts? Recommendations?

Top of the page Bottom of the page
Scott Laz
Posted 2013-05-30 1:31 PM (#5149 - in reply to #5140)
Subject: Re: Magical Realism



Uber User

Posts: 263
100
Location: Gunnison, Colorado		"Do we stop worrying about specific definitions and just read good books with stories that take one or more steps away from "the real world"?" That would be ideal!

I always thought of magical realism as differing from other types of fantasy in that it seems to be set in "the real world", except that magical things happen and people accept these things as normal. For the characters in the stories, and the cultures in which they live, the magical elements are real, and they believe in them, so the story is not fantasy (or so the argument goes). This is different from most genre fantasy, in which the "eruption" of the fantastic into our world is unexpected and strange. There's a real distinction here, but I think magical realism has also become a convenient label for those who want to ensure that literature doesn't get polluted by genre. Magical realism, unlike fantasy, can be "literary" and so is safe to read and enjoy...

It's not magical realism, but I get some of that same feel from Haruki Murakami.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
minervasowl
Posted 2013-06-01 1:08 PM (#5173 - in reply to #5140)
Subject: Re: Magical Realism



Member

Posts: 24
0
Location: New Hampshire		Although I understand your point about classifications, the idea that "literary" fiction is "safe" is another tempting can of worms to open. ;-)

The point about magical events being accepted as normal is well taken, and I think that the key word is "events." Magical people and magical beings tip the scales into fantasy. At least obviously magical people and beings. For example, the setting for Voices of Dragons by Carrie Vaughn is modern and realistic, except for the dragons. In fact, everything other than the dragons is so normal that I found their presence jarring, making the story difficult to read. Even the premise of the story is traditional. There is a boundary dividing humans and dragons. Each is banned from the other's territory. And then one day a girl and a dragon break the rules and become friends. On the other hand, the protagonist in Chocolat clearly has some sort of mystical or magical qualities, but no one labels what she does as magic, at least not in the conjuring sense.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [25 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete all cookies set by this site)